Nominations Clarifications #2

[fadmods]

A few comments and queries in relation to nominations so far:

Dangan Ronpa - All Media Types

Several ships have been nominated under this umbrella fandom. Please renominate with more specific fandom tags, or provide evidence in the comments to support the use of the broad tag.

Wicked - All Media Types

Please specify whether you mean Wicked - Schwartz/Holzman or The Wicked Years Series - Gregory Maguire.





Nominations still needing clarification:

Legend of Zelda & Related Fandoms

Several ships have been nominated under this umbrella fandom. Please renominate with more specific fandom tags, or provide evidence in the comments to support the use of the broad tag.

Poldark - All Media Types

Four ships are currently nominated under this fandom. We would prefer to avoid "All Media Types" fandoms; please adjust to either "Poldark - Winston Graham", "Poldark (TV 1975)" or "Poldark (TV 2015)" as appropriate.

Comments

[(Anonymous)]

This seems inconsistent with how you treated DC Comics in another post; that fandom consists of many different titles and timelines and reboots, but you insisted on keeping it together. But Dangan Ronpa is a much smaller franchise, with a smaller number of characters and plenty of characters who intact between instalments, and it has to be split up? And then you put Homestuck and Hiveswap together, even though they're completely different formats and have totally different casts, which is only going to result in the smaller Hiveswap fandom getting buried. This just seems really inconsistent.

[fadmods]

Hi, thanks for getting in touch.

We're not necessarily aiming for consistency above all else; the main goal is to ensure that the tag set is as manageable as possible both for us on the back end and for participants to use when signing up. This will mean that we're taking decisions on a case by case basis, and indeed part of the point of posts like this one is to help us gather the information we need to make those decisions.